Trip is over, in case anyone is interested, here's the recap of the uke-related bits:
Firstly, Aldrine was on tour... bummer. We saw his fill-in, who was good. Hard to be upset when you're having happy hour beers on a beach in hawaii watching live music.
I'm pretty sure that we hit every store on the island that carried ukes. My dad was looking for a tenor in the > $300 area. I was looking for anything that jumped out at me but most likely not a tenor 4-string because I'm pretty happy with mine and was hoping to find something different. My "official" (make my wife happy) budget was $500 but I was willing to push past that if I fell in love with something.
Scotty's: I read the reviews, and considered meeting Scotty to be part of the experience. He did not disappoint. He is definitely a character and will certainly rub some people the wrong way. When I told him that I was happy with my tenor and was interested in looking at other things, he just wanted to know what kind of tenor I already have (Ko'olau) and proceeded to tell me how much better his offerings were than what I had. He REALLY wanted to sell me a koa tenor and nothing else. He trash talked everything that wasn't the things that he carries, which just left a bad taste in my mouth especially since some things that he said were factually inaccurate. At one point, he literally pulled a uke out of my hands and said "that one's garbage, let me save you from yourself" and hung it back on the wall. To be fair, it was a cheapy little uke with some dust on it, but I thought it was kind of neat looking and wanted to see what it sounded like... oh well. If you want a Kamaka or Kanilea tenor and don't mind dealing with Scotty, you will get a great deal. I can not deny that the deal that he offered me was a good one, it was just more than I wanted to spend on a sort of niche uke (8-string kamaka).
Strings and Things: Really laid back atmosphere. The guy working there spent the whole time playing his guitar, which I kind of enjoyed but he didn't seem to know a ton about ukuleles. He let us play anything that we wanted, so we spent some time there, but didn't find anything very interesting. Mostly Kalas.
kalaheo music and strings: Another nice relaxing place to browse but not that helpful. I literally kept getting one word answers from the guy.
Me: "Who makes those ukuleles with 'Kauai' shaped sound holes?"
Him: "We do"
Me: "Are those solid Koa?"
Him: "Yeah"
Me: "Are they made here on the island?"
Him: "No"
We tried out a bunch of ukes and I bought a Fretboard Roadmaps book.
Larry's in Kapa'a: Mostly Kamoa but had a section of K brands and a few others. We were helped by Joe who was basically the polar opposite of Scotty. Extremely friendly, spent a long time with us. My dad bought a Kamoa that was really happy with. Joe spent about 30 minutes giving me an impromptu lesson and just talking ukes. I really liked the look of the kamoas and was starting to eye a red sunburst concert but didn't pull the trigger but it was about $600 which was over my budget and only about 250 less than a gorgeous kanilea concert that Scotty had (but didn't seem to want to sell me). My dad went back a couple days later to buy a hard case. I kind of think he just wanted to go back to see Joe and he liked that the case said Kamoa on it because he enjoyed the experience so much.
I think I held back a little because I've been eyeing a Pono MTD8, which I ended up ordering the other day from HMS. Was hoping to find one there or something else that I liked better.
Overall, it was great fun. Wish there were more ukes on Kauai though. Almost all of them are either hawaiian-made koa or cheap laminates.