Kmetzger
Well-known member
Ok, here is the answer: the first ukulele is spruce and the second one is Koa - the opposite of what the majority of people guessed in the poll! Which was that two-thirds of people guessed that the first uke in the recording was Koa, when it was not.
My view on all this? I feel my spruce Moore Bettah is richer, warmer and more resonant than my Koa Moore Bettah. I prefer the sound of my spruce uke. So does that mean spruce wins? That I will only buy spruce ukes from this point forward? No. Why?
Chuck said recently "These days my ukes sound remarkably similar despite the wood used". So I would have to say that my spruce uke sounds richer and more resonant than my Koa *not* because of the different tone wood, but because he built the two of them five years apart with different construction methods.
The lesson for me here is that the commonly stated belief in the ukulele community that Koa is warmer and as a result more desirable than what is characterized as bright and brittle spruce, is perhaps an unfounded prejudice/myth. And thus I should not shop based on the tone wood (unless I want something in particular visually) and instead shop based on playability and sound. (Perhaps it is a different issue when it comes to larger instruments like guitars, but that's a debate for a different forum.)
The original thread/poll and link to the sound file is here: http://forum.ukuleleunderground.com/showthread.php?100524-Poll-Can-u-tell-difference-koa-vs-spruce
Thanks to you all for listening and participating in the poll. Was an interesting exercise.
Keith
My view on all this? I feel my spruce Moore Bettah is richer, warmer and more resonant than my Koa Moore Bettah. I prefer the sound of my spruce uke. So does that mean spruce wins? That I will only buy spruce ukes from this point forward? No. Why?
Chuck said recently "These days my ukes sound remarkably similar despite the wood used". So I would have to say that my spruce uke sounds richer and more resonant than my Koa *not* because of the different tone wood, but because he built the two of them five years apart with different construction methods.
The lesson for me here is that the commonly stated belief in the ukulele community that Koa is warmer and as a result more desirable than what is characterized as bright and brittle spruce, is perhaps an unfounded prejudice/myth. And thus I should not shop based on the tone wood (unless I want something in particular visually) and instead shop based on playability and sound. (Perhaps it is a different issue when it comes to larger instruments like guitars, but that's a debate for a different forum.)
The original thread/poll and link to the sound file is here: http://forum.ukuleleunderground.com/showthread.php?100524-Poll-Can-u-tell-difference-koa-vs-spruce
Thanks to you all for listening and participating in the poll. Was an interesting exercise.
Keith