I'm wondering what today's conventional ukulele builder's think of the growing and newly found grass roots support for composite ukuleles. Have any of you guys tried any of these offerings... and what are your thoughts?
Might be worth moving this to the luthier's lounge warndt. More builders kick back there. Let me know if you'd like me to do that. Cheers.
IMHO we want orchestral and similar ensemble instruments to have continuity. Each Selmer Paris Eb clarinet should sound the same when played with the same trained lips on the same quality reed, right? Let the composer's / conductor's instructions, not the idiosyncrasies of the players' hardware, determine the sound.
Solo and small-group instruments are something else -- we want our individuality to show through. We can do that with unique builds, or (as mentioned) by personalizing it by choice of strings or reeds or other aids. My mass-produced Ovation 12-string guitar does NOT sound like all its kin if I swap the course octaves, drop some fluffy cotton or an inflated balloon inside, etc. Composite clones can be similarly customized, yes? I own two nearly-identical cheap Kohala soprano 'ukes. The one with A'Addario t2 strings in gCEA does NOT sound like the other I just strung with a Aquila 5ths set in GDAE. Easy-peasy.
It's not the instrument so much as what we do with it.
The Blackbird tenor has really changed my views on how they sound. Wow
There are definite advantages to carbon fiber instruments. They can sound really good, so nobody is taking a hit on that. Humidity, or lack of humidity, is not a problem for carbon fiber instruments. Where I live, we have to keep the wood instruments in their cases with humidifiers in the winter so they don't dry out and crack. We can leave carbon fiber instruments laying around to be picked up and played whenever we feel like it. I better stop here because I could be talking myself into a carbon fiber ukulele.
Tony