kissing
Well-known member
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2009
- Messages
- 4,364
- Reaction score
- 597
I know there has been some discussion about flat vs radiused fretboards before (though that discussion seemed a bit inconclusive).
Some makers, especially the high-end ones seem to market the radiused fretboard as a feature, that makes playing the ukulele easier for the fretting hand.
However, this video has me questioning the concept of radiused fretboards altogether:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6phVl9PTMMc
Basically he says:
-Radiused fretboards are better for chording, as it accomodates more naturally to the form of the chording hand, but HARDER for intricate fingerpicking, as the strings are also arched.
BUT
-Flat fretboards are better for the fingerpicking hand, as it gives a more uniform height to the strings. Also better for bends higher up the fretboard as a radius can cause the treble string to "choke" or feel higher action.
Lately, going back and forth my various stringed instruments (ukuleles, electric guitars, acoustic guitars, classical guitars), I have been finding this to be somewhat true!
I always wondered why it was so much easier to play fingerstyle on my flat fretted instruments, whereas radiused instruments feel better flat-picked with a plectrum. The vice versa also seems to be true... playing a flat fretboard using a pick seems to feel "strange" compared to using a pick on a radiused fretboard.
Afterall, the intense radius on violins, cello, etc are there to allow for the string angles needed for bowing. Perhaps the radius on guitars helps the person use a plectrum more effectively. Nylon-strung ukuleles being primary finger-picked instruments much like the classical guitars - a flat fretboard makes more sense.
This leads me to question the rationale behind radiused fretboards on some high-end ukes.
Are they just easier for chords + strumming, but a hindrance to fingerpicking?
Or are the effects not significant enough to make a noticeable difference?
An ukulele with a radiused fretboard would also have to have an arched formation in the nut and saddle - so it would affect the positioned heights of the strings relative to a flat fretboard... right?
Given these factors, it leads me to actually prefer a flat fretboard on an ukulele over radiused... !!
Some makers, especially the high-end ones seem to market the radiused fretboard as a feature, that makes playing the ukulele easier for the fretting hand.
However, this video has me questioning the concept of radiused fretboards altogether:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6phVl9PTMMc
Basically he says:
-Radiused fretboards are better for chording, as it accomodates more naturally to the form of the chording hand, but HARDER for intricate fingerpicking, as the strings are also arched.
BUT
-Flat fretboards are better for the fingerpicking hand, as it gives a more uniform height to the strings. Also better for bends higher up the fretboard as a radius can cause the treble string to "choke" or feel higher action.
Lately, going back and forth my various stringed instruments (ukuleles, electric guitars, acoustic guitars, classical guitars), I have been finding this to be somewhat true!
I always wondered why it was so much easier to play fingerstyle on my flat fretted instruments, whereas radiused instruments feel better flat-picked with a plectrum. The vice versa also seems to be true... playing a flat fretboard using a pick seems to feel "strange" compared to using a pick on a radiused fretboard.
Afterall, the intense radius on violins, cello, etc are there to allow for the string angles needed for bowing. Perhaps the radius on guitars helps the person use a plectrum more effectively. Nylon-strung ukuleles being primary finger-picked instruments much like the classical guitars - a flat fretboard makes more sense.
This leads me to question the rationale behind radiused fretboards on some high-end ukes.
Are they just easier for chords + strumming, but a hindrance to fingerpicking?
Or are the effects not significant enough to make a noticeable difference?
An ukulele with a radiused fretboard would also have to have an arched formation in the nut and saddle - so it would affect the positioned heights of the strings relative to a flat fretboard... right?
Given these factors, it leads me to actually prefer a flat fretboard on an ukulele over radiused... !!
Last edited: