I think what Shawn was using was:
D (2220)
F#m (2120)
Em (4432) - sometimes he might be using G (4232) instead
F#m_high (6654)
Bm_high (7675)
Bm (4222)
F#m7 (6657)
There’s something in your eyes (D, F#m)
Is everything alright (D, F#m)
You look up to the sky (Em, F#m_high)
You long for something more darling (Bm_high)
**repeat chord progression for rest of verse
Chorus:
I know that after tonight (Bm)
you don’t have to look up at the stars no no no no (F#m, Bm)
I know by the end tonight (Bm)
you don’t have to look about the stars (F#m, Bm)
And I know that if the love is alright (Bm)
you don’t have to look up at the stars (F#m, Bm)
no no no no (G, F#m_high --> F#m7)
-------------------
But I think what Justin uses in his recording is more like:
Cm (5333)
Gm (3231)
Fm (5543)
G#_high (5346)
Bb (3211)
G# (1343)
Intro: Bb, G#, Bb, G#
There’s something in your eyes (Cm, Gm)
Is everything alright (Cm, Gm)
You look up to the sky (Fm, Gm)
You long for something more darling (G#_high)
Give me your right hand (Bb, G#)
I think I understand (Bb, G#)
Follow me and you will never have to wish again (Fm, Gm, G#_high)
Chorus:
I know that after tonight (Fm, Cm)
you don’t have to look up at the stars no no no no (Gm, Cm)
I know by the end tonight (Fm, Cm)
you don’t have to look about the stars (Gm, Cm)
And I know that if the love is alright (Fm, Cm)
you don’t have to look up at the stars (Gm, Cm)
no no no no (Bb, G#)
Either way, it's a pretty sweet song. Very Mraz-ish.