I only have the gloss, so can't compare....but.....
...when I got it, I was a bit concerned because the gloss finish seemed kind of thick. I thought it would deaden the sound and make it quiet. I was pleasantly surprised this is not the case. It is one of the loudest ukes I've played and the tone is quite beautiful. If that is what you are concerned about, I wouldn't worry. Honestly, I wouldn't want/need it to play any louder.