Noobie
Well-known member
I love reading all of the discussions about how one instrument sounds so much different than another, and what woods sounds like, or strings, etc. But my personal experience with these things is that perception matters more than anything else in subjective things like this. My father used to work in high-end audio, and there were constant debates about whether something "sounded better," even if it couldn't be tested.
I thought it might be fun to take a scientific approach to garner some discussion. All we'd need would be a gathering of ukers and a variety of ukes. Here's how it might work:
* Pick a simple short song or chord progression to play.
* Pick a player who believes they can play fairly consistently.
* Give the player a variety of ukuleles, including high-end and low-end. Give all of the listeners a sheet of paper with the various ukes written down.
* Have the player play the same song on each ukulele, and have the listeners write down a score from 1-5 on how "good" the ukulele sounds to them, and any observations about the sound such as "bright," or "loud."
* Have the player go behind a screen of some type so no one can see what he's playing, and have him play the ukes in a random (but noted) order, and have the listeners rate each one again, and write notes.
* See how they compare.
I have some suspicions as to how the results will turn out, but I'll save them for now.
Are there any uke get togethers out there that might be interested in trying something like this "in the name of science?" It should be a lot of fun, too.
I thought it might be fun to take a scientific approach to garner some discussion. All we'd need would be a gathering of ukers and a variety of ukes. Here's how it might work:
* Pick a simple short song or chord progression to play.
* Pick a player who believes they can play fairly consistently.
* Give the player a variety of ukuleles, including high-end and low-end. Give all of the listeners a sheet of paper with the various ukes written down.
* Have the player play the same song on each ukulele, and have the listeners write down a score from 1-5 on how "good" the ukulele sounds to them, and any observations about the sound such as "bright," or "loud."
* Have the player go behind a screen of some type so no one can see what he's playing, and have him play the ukes in a random (but noted) order, and have the listeners rate each one again, and write notes.
* See how they compare.
I have some suspicions as to how the results will turn out, but I'll save them for now.
Are there any uke get togethers out there that might be interested in trying something like this "in the name of science?" It should be a lot of fun, too.