I wouldn't be too sure of that Vic. We have real life examples of instruments that are over 400 years old (Amati fiddles) and still very much playable. They may have been repaired down the line but 400 years and still going strong isn't my idea of built in obsolescence.
And those are wonderful examples of fine instruments but not examples of planned obsolescence. Those instruments were made out of the finest materials available at the time by master artisans, albeit most likely only for the enjoyment of the aristocracy, in a time of feudalism and a nasty plague that wiped out a 3rd of France's population. Of course the monarchy to follow ended as expected. Someone once said, "History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes."
"We have Glue (Hide) that lasts thousands of years. We also have real life examples of relatively modern materials that are pretty much junk after 30 or 40 years - certain Plastics, Rubber, Nitro Cellulose."
Bingo, planned obsolescence. There is no incentive to create the most scientifically advanced materials for production of consumer goods when a company has to insure profitability.
“Nothing produced can be allowed to maintain a lifespan longer than what can be endured in order to continue cyclical consumption.”
"Take the example of Parchment and modern paper. It doesn't take a genius to work out that the former far outlasts the modern equivalent. There is just a huge difference in the cost.
You might just have to wait the best part of 200 years before passing judgement on the longevity of any modern material."
Another great example would be hemp paper, a paper of the highest archival quality that was used to pen the ever so popular US Declaration of Independence. This paper was done away with in the 30s when a newspaper tycoon by the name of William Randolph Hearst saw its use as a paper product as competition to his 1000s of acres of timber to be used in his rags. Alcohol prohibition had just ended and there was a void in the bureaucracy that needed to be filled, so the war on hemp was started. A successful propaganda campaign ( with many racist overtones ) was waged by said newspapers and hemp was taxed out of existence, eliminating competition for wood pulp and bringing in the wonderful war on drugs and the growing industry of private prisons, prisons whose stock goes up with the increase of prison population...
As far as parchment goes, I'd hate to think about the goat massacre it would take to send out the next Grizzly catalog.
This is a good example of planned obsolescence. I found this half size guitar in the alley while walking to a cookout. From the looks of it, the young lady this belonged to wasn't impressed at all. lol
View attachment 29495
Look closely, staples screws and plywood. I'll use it as a template while changing the bracing and neck joint to make a real guitar of my own.