Goats Can Eat Anything
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jan 28, 2012
- Messages
- 56
- Reaction score
- 0
Hello Fellow UUers:
It's been a hot minute since I have checked in here -- I have been doing a lot of playing.
I'm very, very please with the way my reentrant tuned Collings mahogany tenor has been playing in -- the tone has become sweeter and the dynamic range wider, this, combined with the already thrilling clarity of the instrument has made me one happy guy. I got that one back in February and I haven't bought a uke since then!
But I'm thinking about adding another tenor to the stable. I have a Donaldson super-soprano on order already, so I'm okay with the notion of doubling down on tenors. Also, I want this one to be low-G.
There are two options: 1) get a new reentrant uke and repurpose the Collings as a low-G or 2) get a new low-G uke.
Whichever option, I'm thinking Hawaii-made K-brand.
My thoughts:
1) While I'm not opposed to this idea, it would require widening the string slot on the bridge and I'm really happy with the Collings in this role. On the one hand, if it ain't broke... On the other, that attitude may needlessly close some doors -- might there be a reentrant tenor that I like more???
2) This makes a lot of sense because a reputable retailer like HMS would get it set up with low-G fluorocarbons at no additional cost and I suspect they (along with my fellow UUers) could steer me in the direction of the right uke with which to do it.
But, you ask, which K brand?
Leading contender: Kanilea -- I like the look, really like the fit and finish, and I have enjoyed the sound that I hear on comparative test videos. The clarity and upper midrange focus (at least what I perceive to be) would, in my mind, lend itself well to the broader frequency range of low-G. The K-1 gloss looks great, the premium looks a little better. I understand that figure is not an aid to tone. But, I like pretty wood and the $200 wouldn't change my world. I hear they have some pretty good customer service too.
Another strong contender: Ko'olau -- the look is fine (reminds me of Larivee guitars) and beat on the street is that their F+F is also quite good. The videos show a clear and balanced tone throughout the range of notes and dynamics. Gloss adds some cost and they look like Ponos. But if there is a reason why this would be better for my purposes, I'm really open to it.
Lesser contender: Kamaka -- with the factory strings confined in a trash can, these things sound pretty good. However, the F+F is a very serious negative. I really hate the orange peel effect. But, I could get past it if there was a really, really, really compelling reason.
Non-contender: Koaloha -- for all of the amazing things that I hear about their tone and customer service, I can't get past the design. I know they are loved, but I hate the look. I wish that didn't matter, but it does.
OK -- so with all of that in mind, what do you guys think would be the best low-G uke for me? I mix between strumming and fingerstyle. I like clarity, focus, and depth in tone. I'd rather it not be a quiet uke, but loud is not especially important.
Thanks for the thoughts!
It's been a hot minute since I have checked in here -- I have been doing a lot of playing.
I'm very, very please with the way my reentrant tuned Collings mahogany tenor has been playing in -- the tone has become sweeter and the dynamic range wider, this, combined with the already thrilling clarity of the instrument has made me one happy guy. I got that one back in February and I haven't bought a uke since then!
But I'm thinking about adding another tenor to the stable. I have a Donaldson super-soprano on order already, so I'm okay with the notion of doubling down on tenors. Also, I want this one to be low-G.
There are two options: 1) get a new reentrant uke and repurpose the Collings as a low-G or 2) get a new low-G uke.
Whichever option, I'm thinking Hawaii-made K-brand.
My thoughts:
1) While I'm not opposed to this idea, it would require widening the string slot on the bridge and I'm really happy with the Collings in this role. On the one hand, if it ain't broke... On the other, that attitude may needlessly close some doors -- might there be a reentrant tenor that I like more???
2) This makes a lot of sense because a reputable retailer like HMS would get it set up with low-G fluorocarbons at no additional cost and I suspect they (along with my fellow UUers) could steer me in the direction of the right uke with which to do it.
But, you ask, which K brand?
Leading contender: Kanilea -- I like the look, really like the fit and finish, and I have enjoyed the sound that I hear on comparative test videos. The clarity and upper midrange focus (at least what I perceive to be) would, in my mind, lend itself well to the broader frequency range of low-G. The K-1 gloss looks great, the premium looks a little better. I understand that figure is not an aid to tone. But, I like pretty wood and the $200 wouldn't change my world. I hear they have some pretty good customer service too.
Another strong contender: Ko'olau -- the look is fine (reminds me of Larivee guitars) and beat on the street is that their F+F is also quite good. The videos show a clear and balanced tone throughout the range of notes and dynamics. Gloss adds some cost and they look like Ponos. But if there is a reason why this would be better for my purposes, I'm really open to it.
Lesser contender: Kamaka -- with the factory strings confined in a trash can, these things sound pretty good. However, the F+F is a very serious negative. I really hate the orange peel effect. But, I could get past it if there was a really, really, really compelling reason.
Non-contender: Koaloha -- for all of the amazing things that I hear about their tone and customer service, I can't get past the design. I know they are loved, but I hate the look. I wish that didn't matter, but it does.
OK -- so with all of that in mind, what do you guys think would be the best low-G uke for me? I mix between strumming and fingerstyle. I like clarity, focus, and depth in tone. I'd rather it not be a quiet uke, but loud is not especially important.
Thanks for the thoughts!