Doc_J
Well-known member
Some folks (including luthiers) say the top wood doesn't matter so much on a uke as compared to a guitar. The uke design and build are said to be more important. For example, the Mya-moes of different wood and tops all sound pretty similar. I guess this is from the individual "voicing" of their tops. Other folks/luthiers prefer softwood tops. Maybe this is really just dependent on the luthier's design and approach to building ukes. From my limited experience I think that soft wood tops do help create a great sounding uke. I'm not sure I like the looks of soft wood tops. Cedar and redwood seem to be popular tops along with spruce. Some side and back hardwood combinations look good (redwood and Myrtle, Walnut and cedar, rosewood and spruce, etc.) . I've noticed most uke manufactures have added softwood tops to their line over the last couple of years.
A couple of my best sounding ukes are sitka spruce tops. I have a cedar top too, that seems to soften and darken the tone in a good way. I had a redwood top uke that quite frankly I did not enjoy. Redwood seemed to be way too soft and affected the treble end of the sound in an unflattering way, but it did have some nice bass and low frequency harmonics. It also dented very easy. I had a good luthier talk me out of redwood once in favor of spruce, early in my uke playing. Glad I listened to him, as the resulting uke was excellent. I have also heard Port Orford cedar has some nice properties too (yes, I know it really is a cypress ).
So, I right now, spruce is my favorite softwood top material. It seems stronger than redwood or cedar, doesn't darken any sound, and projects well, too. I've never tried the different varieties of spruce tone wood (Engelmann , Adirondack , etc). Maybe some folks have preferences for these?
Anyways just wanted to get the discussion rolling. Let me know what experiences (good or bad) you have had with softwood tops, and how well you like them.
A couple of my best sounding ukes are sitka spruce tops. I have a cedar top too, that seems to soften and darken the tone in a good way. I had a redwood top uke that quite frankly I did not enjoy. Redwood seemed to be way too soft and affected the treble end of the sound in an unflattering way, but it did have some nice bass and low frequency harmonics. It also dented very easy. I had a good luthier talk me out of redwood once in favor of spruce, early in my uke playing. Glad I listened to him, as the resulting uke was excellent. I have also heard Port Orford cedar has some nice properties too (yes, I know it really is a cypress ).
So, I right now, spruce is my favorite softwood top material. It seems stronger than redwood or cedar, doesn't darken any sound, and projects well, too. I've never tried the different varieties of spruce tone wood (Engelmann , Adirondack , etc). Maybe some folks have preferences for these?
Anyways just wanted to get the discussion rolling. Let me know what experiences (good or bad) you have had with softwood tops, and how well you like them.
Last edited: