Stompfrog
Active member
This week I treated myself to a couple of new books on guitar building...
The Luthier's Handbook
Guitarmaking: Tradition and Technology
I've literally only just started the second book but completed the first one last night.
The luthiers handbook was very interesting. It was all about the science of acoustics and tone. It was very detailed and was clearly written by someone with a great deal of knowledge and experience. It was however, in my opinion a fairly daunting read for the amateur luthier.
I feel fairly confident that I can make an instrument that looks presentable and isn't a total pig to play but this book isn't about that at all. It's explains, in detail how each component of a guitar affects the tone and how those parts interact.
I have definitely learned a lot about how guitars make sound and I am sure this will effect my designs and processes whilst making instruments. However, overall I didn't really enjoy reading it.
In places the book seemed kind of arrogant and patronising. I think this is best illustrated by the following paragraph.
"Sounds complicated. Not really. Read it again."
I usually finish guitar building books on a huge high and run off to ebay to search for wood and tools, or go and play my favourite guitar and marvel in its beauty. After finishing this book I felt like no matter how hard I tried I was only likely to make a mediocre acoustic instrument at best.
I'm hoping that as time goes on I will revisit the book as and when specific bits are relevant to the challenges I am facing. Maybe then I will fully appreciate it.
Has anyone else read either of these books? If so, what did you think?
Any suggestions as to what I should read next?
The Luthier's Handbook
Guitarmaking: Tradition and Technology
I've literally only just started the second book but completed the first one last night.
The luthiers handbook was very interesting. It was all about the science of acoustics and tone. It was very detailed and was clearly written by someone with a great deal of knowledge and experience. It was however, in my opinion a fairly daunting read for the amateur luthier.
I feel fairly confident that I can make an instrument that looks presentable and isn't a total pig to play but this book isn't about that at all. It's explains, in detail how each component of a guitar affects the tone and how those parts interact.
I have definitely learned a lot about how guitars make sound and I am sure this will effect my designs and processes whilst making instruments. However, overall I didn't really enjoy reading it.
In places the book seemed kind of arrogant and patronising. I think this is best illustrated by the following paragraph.
"Sounds complicated. Not really. Read it again."
I usually finish guitar building books on a huge high and run off to ebay to search for wood and tools, or go and play my favourite guitar and marvel in its beauty. After finishing this book I felt like no matter how hard I tried I was only likely to make a mediocre acoustic instrument at best.
I'm hoping that as time goes on I will revisit the book as and when specific bits are relevant to the challenges I am facing. Maybe then I will fully appreciate it.
Has anyone else read either of these books? If so, what did you think?
Any suggestions as to what I should read next?