Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 16

Thread: Considering an N. American custom build for an inept strummer

  1. #1

    Lightbulb Considering an N. American custom build for an inept strummer

    Hi folks,

    A year from now I will be on a trip to the US from Europe.
    I am 4 years into being a beginner uke player who came from zero musical background or aptitude. It's slow going but my life is richer for it.

    I am half thinking of building a new, nice, forever? Uke into my trip. This is pointlessly extravagant, but maybe something I can do.

    If I were to do it, and knowing I am mostly a kitchen Strummer and my progress will be slow and I seem to be happiest with concert scale but also enjoy soprano (tenor seems to be a bit of stretch still as I tend to play mostly on the first frets (kitchen Strummer)

    All that being said, who/what would you recommend, and
    which builders mastery artistry would be particularly wasted on me.

    Or am I better leaving all of this idea aside and buying the ldfm that's available in the marketplace because I won't find any thing better per unit cost?? (scale length and playing style be damned)

    Thaks anyway

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Pickering, ON, Canada
    Posts
    5,843

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by steveholt View Post
    Hi folks,

    A year from now I will be on a trip to the US from Europe.
    I am 4 years into being a beginner uke player who came from zero musical background or aptitude. It's slow going but my life is richer for it.

    I am half thinking of building a new, nice, forever? Uke into my trip. This is pointlessly extravagant, but maybe something I can do.

    If I were to do it, and knowing I am mostly a kitchen Strummer and my progress will be slow and I seem to be happiest with concert scale but also enjoy soprano (tenor seems to be a bit of stretch still as I tend to play mostly on the first frets (kitchen Strummer)

    All that being said, who/what would you recommend, and
    which builders mastery artistry would be particularly wasted on me.

    Or am I better leaving all of this idea aside and buying the ldfm that's available in the marketplace because I won't find any thing better per unit cost?? (scale length and playing style be damned)

    Thaks anyway
    I was going to ask your budget but now that you mentioned the LFDM can I assume it is around $2500. You mentioned preferring a concert scale, what ukuleles do you own now, what wood combo and do you prefer a warm or bright sound.

    Don’t give a thought to being “not worthy” of an expensive custom build, I am not worthy of any of mine. If you love to play, it brings you joy and you appreciate fine craftsmanship you qualify.
    Currently enjoying these ukuleles : *LdfM tenor, *LfdM 19" super tenor. *LfdM baritone, *I'iwi tenor , *Koolau tenor, *Webber tenor, *Kimo tenor, *Kimo super concert, *Mya Moe baritone, *Kamaka baritone, *Gianinni baritone, *Fred Shields super soprano, *Kala super soprano, *Loprinzi super soprano, *Black bear ULO concert , *Enya X1 concert, *Enya X1 pineapple soprano, *Gretsch tenor, *Korala plastic concert

  3. #3

    Default

    Hey, thanks for the quick replies from multiple perspectives.

    So -

    What do I play now, and I guess why this idea even appeals.

    I play a Ken Timms Soprano (which my wife hates the barky sound of)
    and an Anuenue africa mahogany concert which she tolerates the sound of more. It's sweeter and softer when strummed in my kitchen, and still sounds good with rudimentary finger picking.

    Prior to these I owned a KM ukes super concert (all cherry) which felt so lively and sounded amazing, and so so so sweet when finger picked, but after a year I faced that Tenor scale and finger picking oriented as this uke was - It wasnt the right scale length for me. Strumming this felt a little like I was doing this uke wrong.
    And from a very generous friend I got to spend a lot of time playing a Myamoe all myrtle super soprano. This might be my favourite uke I have played. It sounded so sweet when strummed, much mellower than the timms. It wasnt the loudest uke in the worlds, which again actually suits my life, but it plays like butter and likes being strummed and sounds sweet to me.

    So what do I think I want - bright vs warm. I am open to ideas I think. The Concert Anuenue is a very full warm sounding uke to me. Maybe I'd like something to approximate a 3 chord strumming guitarist, but in a uke. I'd like something that plays as smoothly and as easily as the Myamoe - does than mean radius fretboard, or just really well made?

    Should I look for something complemetary to the Anuenue I have re: bright vs warm? Or should I look for something that is just 'better' ?

    I think Concert Scale, happy to be strummed. perhaps radius fretboard, and maybe side sound port (as I mostly play to myself) and really really well built are what I'd look at.
    As for looks - good looking wood, little interest in inlays, well executed gloss body with a satin neck. Binding would be nice as part of a total look - but thats behind build quality and play ability factors for me.

    Thats a start.

    From the other side - What are Martin Concerts like? Should I just get a Koa concert from Martin/a highly regarded maker? Whats the best warm option?

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Saratoga, CA
    Posts
    904

    Default

    You are casting too wide a net. Do you want to meet the luthier in person? That would narrow it down based on the cities you plan to or can go to.. or are you trying to save on shipping by receiving if while in US? Or are you planning to work around limitations for shipping due to woods you desire?
    you can order a uke today and have it shipped to you.. so what will be special about you traveling to the US? The Ken Timms I own would not be more special if I picked it up while in U.K. unless I was meeting him..
    I guess what I am trying to say is that decide what will make it special if you were to buy it as part of the trip..
    Last edited by kerneltime; 11-01-2019 at 04:11 AM.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Saratoga, CA
    Posts
    904

    Default

    If anything travel to pistol river Oregon ( beautiful place just look at google images) and buy a Les Stansell baritone. He does not ship and you have to buy it in person. His workshop is amazing and has usually a bunch of ukes ready. That would make it special and something you cannot do from a couch. He makes ukes from PoC, Myrtle typically and they have a very beautiful warm sound. He has a YouTube channel where you can find him playing his ukes (he is a pretty good musician and has a local band he is part of).

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Saratoga, CA
    Posts
    904

    Default

    If you do land up traveling to Oregon and Washington you can meet a whole bunch of folks: Les Stansell, Ono, Beansprout, Mark Roberts, Oceana.. many more..

  7. #7

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by kerneltime View Post
    You are casting too wide a net. Do you want to meet the luthier in person? That would narrow it down based on the cities you plan to or can go to.. or are you trying to save on shipping by receiving if while in US? Or are you planning to work around limitations for shipping due to woods you desire?
    you can order a uke today and have it shipped to you.. so what will be special about you traveling to the US? The Ken Timms I own would not be more special if I picked it up while in U.K. unless I was meeting him..
    I guess what I am trying to say is that decide what will make it special if you were to buy it as part of the trip..
    Hey

    So i'll try narrow an idea down.

    Do you want to meet the luthier in person? - That would be lovely if possible. I am interested in uke building too, so the whole thing would be quite informative. It's an intimidating idea - I am a shy person, but if things were to fall in such a way. I'd like to maybe meet the luthier. This is nice to have, but not critical.

    That would narrow it down based on the cities you plan to or can go to.. or are you trying to save on shipping by receiving if while in US? Or are you planning to work around limitations for shipping due to woods you desire?

    Are you trying to save on shipping by receiving if while in US? Or are you planning to work around limitations for shipping due to woods you desire?

    Saving on shipping, and tax and customs duties is indeed part of this exercise, as is working around limitations on shipping of materials. This is part of it, but not everything.

    you can order a uke today and have it shipped to you.. so what will be special about you traveling to the US?

    This is part of the weirdness of this whole thing. I will be in work, in the pacific northwest for a while next year. I like to build something personal into my trips when I can. I would have no problem doing a 1 man road trip of several days to make something happen. A custom build uke is a big chunk of change. If I commit to it now, I can chip away at the cost over the build time and then go over, collect it - and effectively use the savings on shipping and customs and taxes (maybe 30% on top of the sticker price for me in europe) to fund that little adventure. I'll get to see a part of the world I would not have otherwise, and have a little story too.

    Based on the replies Oregon is a rich place to look. I'll check out the names you have posted. How do Les Stansell and Ono compare to say Kinnard and Hive for consistently high quality?? Beansprout is on my radar due to the Myamoe connection. I will have to check out Mark Roberts and Oceana as I have been unaware of them until now.

    Thanks for the replies kerneltime.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Saratoga, CA
    Posts
    904

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by steveholt View Post
    Hey

    So i'll try narrow an idea down.

    Do you want to meet the luthier in person? - That would be lovely if possible. I am interested in uke building too, so the whole thing would be quite informative. It's an intimidating idea - I am a shy person, but if things were to fall in such a way. I'd like to maybe meet the luthier. This is nice to have, but not critical.

    That would narrow it down based on the cities you plan to or can go to.. or are you trying to save on shipping by receiving if while in US? Or are you planning to work around limitations for shipping due to woods you desire?

    Are you trying to save on shipping by receiving if while in US? Or are you planning to work around limitations for shipping due to woods you desire?

    Saving on shipping, and tax and customs duties is indeed part of this exercise, as is working around limitations on shipping of materials. This is part of it, but not everything.

    you can order a uke today and have it shipped to you.. so what will be special about you traveling to the US?

    This is part of the weirdness of this whole thing. I will be in work, in the pacific northwest for a while next year. I like to build something personal into my trips when I can. I would have no problem doing a 1 man road trip of several days to make something happen. A custom build uke is a big chunk of change. If I commit to it now, I can chip away at the cost over the build time and then go over, collect it - and effectively use the savings on shipping and customs and taxes (maybe 30% on top of the sticker price for me in europe) to fund that little adventure. I'll get to see a part of the world I would not have otherwise, and have a little story too.

    Based on the replies Oregon is a rich place to look. I'll check out the names you have posted. How do Les Stansell and Ono compare to say Kinnard and Hive for consistently high quality?? Beansprout is on my radar due to the Myamoe connection. I will have to check out Mark Roberts and Oceana as I have been unaware of them until now.

    Thanks for the replies kerneltime.
    I have a Hive and am on the wait list and I have 2 Les Stansells. I have played Kinnard but they are not my taste.
    Hive and Les Stansell both focus on very light builds but have very different personalities. Les is making ukes now as he wishes and does not take orders, you will not find him selling a baritone that he does not like.. plus when you visit him you can pick.. Also, he has some amazing access to top quality locally sourced wood.
    Hive are amazing and that is why I am on the list. I bought mine second hand and decided to get another.. I don’t think his 2 year wait list will align with your trip but you can ask..
    I have met David from Ono when I got a uke from him. The scale of the instrument was not to my liking (super tenor) and that is why sold it but I do plan to get another ukes from him next year. David too is doing this purely for his passion and has been continuously improving his builds.
    Last edited by kerneltime; 11-01-2019 at 06:31 AM.

  9. #9

    Default

    Thanks for the options to think about.

    Might I ask - How do you see Hive and Stansell being two different takes on the light and responsive type of build? The KM ukes Super-concery I had was remarkably light and responsive. Pretty much humming in your hands, and so responsive - but this felt more tuned or a better fit to finger picking (even in my clumsy hands).

    What is it about kinnard that was not to your liking - are they built to different targets?
    Where do Ono ukes fit into this spectrum of build styles? (Before I started this thread, I think Ono was tbf the most likely builder I was going to approach - I just seem to like his 'vibe' and his location is pretty close to where I will be visiting for the most part.)

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Saratoga, CA
    Posts
    904

    Default

    I don’t think I am qualified to give an informed opinion about the differences. Here is my understanding, Les builds essentially a flamenco style uke based on his background. The top back and sides are thin and stiff, the strings tend to be of lower tension. Hive from what I can tell have heavier back and sides but a thin top. Also, Les usually builds baritones only where as Hive mostly builds tenors. Ono has been influenced by compass Rose that used to be build by Jake who owns Hive.. in my opinion Ono is closer to Hive and Beau Hannam than Les. Pepe Romero is closer to Les.. Kinnard in my limited opinion is influenced by steel string guitars and likes higher tension.
    The folks above make amazing ukes and I am only giving an uneducated opinion about a question that seeks depth..
    Also, each uke is different.. when I was at Les’ workshop I got to try a few, they all sounded amazing but I liked one more than the others..

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •