bobhost
Well-known member
On the Facebook UU page I saw a handwritten tab for this song from a gentleman from Taiwan (?) named 郭奈良(Guo Nailiang?) along with this video
https://youtu.be/UcCi8OknQbw
Here is the original (reduced to fit better, link to full res version at bottom)
And my best attempt at transcribing it into Musescore (again, reduced res to fit)
I have 2 issues with this tab;
First, measures 4, 12 and 25 all start with 2242. My ear cannot justify this. I wonder if it actually being played x242 with the full bar on 2 being in place for playing later in the measure. What to your eyes and ears say?
Video time 0:12, 0:37 and 1:19
Second, as written measure 20 confuses me. I gave it a shot in transcribing what I could only describe as a syncopated tripled with grace notes thrown in. My ear hears this passage as played in the video 0:53
What do you think? I think I am going to go with the 'as played' passage. Other than these 2 issues, do you have any input on the layout or accuracy of the piece?
Full Res original handwritten tab
Full Res transcription as written
https://youtu.be/UcCi8OknQbw
Here is the original (reduced to fit better, link to full res version at bottom)
And my best attempt at transcribing it into Musescore (again, reduced res to fit)
I have 2 issues with this tab;
First, measures 4, 12 and 25 all start with 2242. My ear cannot justify this. I wonder if it actually being played x242 with the full bar on 2 being in place for playing later in the measure. What to your eyes and ears say?
Video time 0:12, 0:37 and 1:19
Second, as written measure 20 confuses me. I gave it a shot in transcribing what I could only describe as a syncopated tripled with grace notes thrown in. My ear hears this passage as played in the video 0:53
What do you think? I think I am going to go with the 'as played' passage. Other than these 2 issues, do you have any input on the layout or accuracy of the piece?
Full Res original handwritten tab
Full Res transcription as written