Doctroid
Well-known member
IMO, new members, or 'new to forums' members, need guidance and explanations, not intimidation and restrictions. Most are reluctant to take a step too far when they first start posting anyway, and most will be reasonable enough to accept guidance by others if they mess up.
Emphatically agree. Forcing new members to jump through hoops before they are granted the privilege of being treated as an equal would be an enormous mistake. That sends a message: "You're not welcome here until you prove you're good enough for us."
The present setup informs new users well enough, and welcomes them warmly, and if first mistakes are gently corrected and repeat infractions are not tolerated, then I see no reason to impose restrictions or requirements.