Advice Please for Uke Group Wanting to Take First Steps Towards Amplification

hollisdwyer

UU VIP
UU VIP
Joined
Jan 29, 2014
Messages
1,736
Reaction score
374
Location
Melbourne, Australia
I'm no newbie to individual instrument amplification and have had experience as a film sound recordist, but I have no experience with designing a reasonably priced sound system for the Uke group that I am currently playing with.
I would appreciate some guidance for these parameters:
Group size: 12-20 (depends on the weather)
Playing environment: Mainly indoors (medium sized rooms) but sometimes outdoors.
Some of the players have their own amps but most do not or even own instruments with pickups.
1-4 serious lead singers so require voice mics. (I have always like the Shure SM58).
I'm thinking a PA, a small field mixer and 2-3 mics might be the most flexible way to go but would greatly appreciate all thoughts and advice from those who have faced the same requirements.
Cheers!
 
I have been going through live sound equipment for my 50 person uke group for a couple of years. I finally settled on this;

6 Samson mics (SM58 knockoffs)
6 Nu-X wireless mic adapters (maximum of 6 channels and why I chose six mics, also I don't want to deal with mic cables)
An 8 channel analog mixer (inexpensive with 8 XLR inputs, tried a WiFi Behringer but got too much interference)
6 mic stands that collapse very small (actually they're drum mic stands to which I added a longer boom for people)

I plug it into my Carvin Bass amp, but any P/A would work.

My mixer wireless 1024.jpg



This is Michael Kohan in Los Angeles, Beverly West near the Beverly Center
9 tenor cutaway ukes, 5 acoustic bass ukes, 11 solid body bass ukes, 11 mini electric bass guitars (Total: 35)

• Donate to The Ukulele Kids Club, they provide ukuleles to children in hospital music therapy programs. www.theukc.org
• Member The CC Strummers: YouTube: www.youtube.com/user/CCStrummers/video, Facebook: www.facebook.com/TheCCStrummers
 
I have been going through live sound equipment for my 50 person uke group for a couple of years. I finally settled on this;

6 Samson mics (SM58 knockoffs)
6 Nu-X wireless mic adapters (maximum of 6 channels and why I chose six mics, also I don't want to deal with mic cables)
An 8 channel analog mixer (inexpensive with 8 XLR inputs, tried a WiFi Behringer but got too much interference)
6 mic stands that collapse very small (actually they're drum mic stands to which I added a longer boom for people)

I plug it into my Carvin Bass amp, but any P/A would work.

My mixer wireless 1024.jpg



This is Michael Kohan in Los Angeles, Beverly West near the Beverly Center
9 tenor cutaway ukes, 5 acoustic bass ukes, 11 solid body bass ukes, 11 mini electric bass guitars (Total: 35)

• Donate to The Ukulele Kids Club, they provide ukuleles to children in hospital music therapy programs. www.theukc.org
• Member The CC Strummers: YouTube: www.youtube.com/user/CCStrummers/video, Facebook: www.facebook.com/TheCCStrummers

Thanks very much for your advice. That looks like a good end goal for the group but gives me a pathway to start at.

One question though, are the various SM58 knockoffs close enough in quality to justify not spending the extra on the original Shure model?
 
One question though, are the various SM58 knockoffs close enough in quality to justify not spending the extra on the original Shure model?

Don't get me started on Shure SM-58's. The real question is, who doesn't make a SM-58 knock off that's better than the original.:mad:
I was just at a regular blackboard gig last night that uses Shure SM-58's just like everyone else and the sound was mud, mud, mud, mud. Mud is what SM-58's are know for and that's what we got. People were listening intently at this gig to understand the lyrics but most couldn't make them out.
Funnily enough, I personally am one of the few singers with the power and vocal intelligibility to make an SM-58 work for me but I still don't like them.
end rant on SM-58's/

As to the PA system. Are you going to have someone running the PA?
A pair of XY pattern condensers for the uke orchestra and 4 vocal mics for lead singers is a LOT to contend with and isn't really suitable for a set and forget sound reenforcement setup. PA's for largish groups is rather complicated and needs an experienced sound person to run it. When you get an experienced sound person I would ask them for advice. If performers start wanting foldback monitors as well then it gets quite complicated to run.

You'd be surprised how complicated just running two mics, a foldback monitor and a couple of main speakers can be.
 
Last edited:
Thanks very much for your advice. That looks like a good end goal for the group but gives me a pathway to start at. One question though, are the various SM58 knockoffs close enough in quality to justify not spending the extra on the original Shure model?

I think they sound very good. One of the reasons I good a mixer is to have better control of the mic sound with 3 band equalizers on each channel, helps a lot with variations in mics.
 
Don't get me started on Shure SM-58's. The real question is, who doesn't make a SM-58 knock off that's better than the original.:mad:
I was just at a regular blackboard gig last night that uses Shure SM-58's just like everyone else and the sound was mud, mud, mud, mud. Mud is what SM-58's are know for and that's what we got. People were listening intently at this gig to understand the lyrics but most couldn't make them out.
Funnily enough, I personally am one of the few singers with the power and vocal intelligibility to make an SM-58 work for me but I still don't like them.
end rant on SM-58's/

As to the PA system. Are you going to have someone running the PA?
A pair of XY pattern condensers for the uke orchestra and 4 vocal mics for lead singers is a LOT to contend with and isn't really suitable for a set and forget sound reenforcement setup. PA's for largish groups is rather complicated and needs an experienced sound person to run it. When you get an experienced sound person I would ask them for advice. If performers start wanting foldback monitors as well then it gets quite complicated to run.

You'd be surprised how complicated just running two mics, a foldback monitor and a couple of main speakers can be.

I think they sound very good. One of the reasons I good a mixer is to have better control of the mic sound with 3 band equalizers on each channel, helps a lot with variations in mics.

Well, there's two responses that represent the polarity of opinion!

That begs the question, if not a SM58, what would people recommend up to the same cost? I have a ZT Acoustic amp ( https://www.ztamplifiers.com/lunchbox-acoustic-amp.html ) that has a mic channel and provides EQ on that channel. As a first step to amping our group it will probably be this amp which will be used for our vocalists.
 
That begs the question, if not a SM58, what would people recommend up to the same cost? I have a ZT Acoustic amp (link deleted) that has a mic channel and provides EQ on that channel. As a first step to amping our group it will probably be this amp which will be used for our vocalists.

SM-58's are a victim of their own success. They can't change and they can't get better because everyone is just so used to them and want's them. Anyway, if all you need is an SM-58 then you can get the same performance for WAY less with an iSK DM-58 or a Behringer XM8500. For the money of a new Shure SM-58 I believe that people really should try out a few mics at a good store and pick a mic that works for their own voice.

Amplifying a large group of performers is not something I would recommend that any one tries to do on the cheap or for a lark. It's actually quite a difficult technical thing to do.
 
Last edited:
I second anthonyg's recommendation of the Behringer XM8500 ($20 or less in the U.S.), and I suggest a Rode M1 (from the OP's and ag's homeland) as a substitute for the default SM58. The price is the same (at least in the U.S.) = $99.
 
You're in for a headache. My recommendation is as follows:

First, remember that you only need to be heard. You don't need to be loud.

The simplest setup would be a x/y microphone up high in front of the group, but this is not necessarily the cheapest, and getting a good balance between the voices and instruments may prove difficult. You could add a cardioid condenser several feet to either side of the x/y setup as needs demand. This approach makes it easy for the group to monitor their own sound and grants the flexibility for soloists to approach the various microphones for a natural boost.

Alternatively, groups of 3-4 ensemble members could each share 1 cardioid microphone set at a height about halfway between their ukes and mouths. The groups could each be built around one lead singer, with the remaining players being assigned based on their height. The members could then use spacing from the microphones to control dynamics. This method allows you to push higher SPLs but also requires considerable discipline on the part of ensemble members.

Either way, I would restrict instrument amp use to only one or two reliable rhythm or lead players (possibly with a good singer on the amp's xlr channel). Set the amp to a low level and use it as a monitor to minimize bleed. You can then mic the speaker cabinet if you need it in the mix.

Neither of these solutions is perfect, but either one is accessible.
 
Our uke club uses an older Peavy PVi 8500, eight channel, powered mixer to power a PA with two speakers and a monitor. (I don't know the brand offhand.)

We generally run 4 Shure SM58 mics. (We got the ones with switches, and finally taped the switches in the on position.) And four instruments. But any mix of plugged in instruments and mics will work.

It does a decent job. Perfect, no. But the electric ukes sound pretty good. And the mics work pretty well for both voice and instruments. Not too much trouble with feedback and pretty easily stopped with the mixer.

The mics are rugged. As is the mixer amp. It's reasonably portable. It can handle passive and active pickups. And the sound is good overall. It delivers a lot for the price. It's about 5 years old, been to lots of gigs and is used 50 Wednesday nights a year. (Barring bad snow and ice storms.)
 
Top Bottom