My youngest recently figured out that when I'm choked up and try to keep the tears in I jerk with little internal sobs, but no tears fall.
Curses, now she watches me closely when we watch things like the Notebook. Luckily they play the Notebook so often that I've become callous.
Rudy
It's a Wonderful Life
Finding Nemo
The Incredibles ("You keep trying to pick a fight, but I'm just happy you're alive.")
Saving Private Ryan
Sound of Music
Monsters Inc.
The last two need some 'splanin, but luckily I wrote a blog post about it a while back,
here.
Maybe we should also list what doesn't make us cry even though it makes a lot of others cry.
Click and Titanic top that list for me.
I don't remember crying at Up, but I probably did, one soulmate dying before getting to their big adventure sounds tear jerking but I don't remember it. When I even think of Private Ryan at the end when he questions his value it makes me tear up. Up just doesn't do that for me.
I also don't tear up for baseball movies. I hate baseball.